Wednesday, January 8, 2014


What I've Learned From My Side Job Critiquing Dick Pics

In September this year, I woke up to an excellent dick pic. I can remember it quite clearly: it was a low-lit shot of a firmly-erect penis straining sideways through boxers, and I was thrilled to receive it: it was subtle, it wasn’t unsolicited, and it was unusually sexy for a Snapchatted cock shot. It also changed the trajectory of my life. I don’t want to send anyone’s ego out of the stratosphere by saying that, but it’s not really an exaggeration: after I received that photo, invigorated and shot through with dopamine, I tweeted about how rare and encouraging it was to receive a decent dick pic. That sparked an online conversation about how to improve the dismal state of dick pics—I would classify them as generally dull, artless and unsolicited—and that lead to my rise as the Internet’s most beloved dick pic critic.

I started Critique My Dick Pic (Not! Safe! For! Work!, and that goes for all links throughout) that same day; a blog with a simple, self-explanatory premise: men (and other people with penises) send me pictures of their dicks, and I critique them with love. “With love” refers to my policy of being neutral about the size of someone’s dick and refusing to shame sender’s bodies, but it’s not about being saccharine or coddling: I don’t mince my words when someone sends me a thoughtless, lazy shot (although I do still try to be somewhat encouraging and constructive).

The fact that I don’t critique actual dicks is difficult to fully communicate to men: I still get dozens of emails asking me for private dick reviews, and requests to describe the “perfect penis." That’s pointless to me, and I’m never going to do it. Just imagine it: imagine, for example, if I decided that the perfect dick is shaped like a coke can, and it’s uncircumcised, and it has visible veins (but not too many), and it’s rock hard and dead straight. Where does that leave people with thin dicks? Veiny dicks? Dicks that veer to one side? Are they supposed to feel shitty and miserable about a body part they can’t change because of the idiosyncratic ideals of some woman from New Zealand they were never going to fuck anyway? It’s nonsense. I find the idea of a “perfect dick” reductive and insidious, and I often have to underline the fact that I’m not here to critique dicks, I’m here to critique dick pics.

The obvious question, then, is what makes a good dick pic? I’m often asked this, and I consistently repeat a few key tips: don’t send a log. Realize the power of your hands to transform a dick pic from ordinary to wettie-inducing. Pay attention to the background and setting of your picture, and understand how off-putting a visible pile of dirty laundry or extremely mundane collection of shower gels can be. Be aware that even a very small amount of thought and consideration for the desires of your receiver will set you apart from most dick pic senders, and take advantage of that by putting more than three second’s thought into the pose, composition and lighting of your picture. Having said that, though, it’s difficult to prescribe an ideal dick pic. Some of the most memorable pictures I’ve received I never saw coming. I wouldn’t have thought to recommend dusting your half-naked body with bone fragments, for example. 

I “indefinitely deprioritize” (ahem) at least half of the dick pics I receive, maybe more than that. If that sounds discouraging, bear with me: every day I receive dozens more pictures than I could ever hope to review, and an alarming amount of them are still of terrible quality. I get hundreds of emails from men who clearly don’t read the blog and just want to flick a whip-it-out, zero-effort cock shot at anyone who’ll look at it. I’m not here for that. A good way for submitters to make sure that their picture will feature on the site is for them to send me their absolute best effort in the form of one single pictureI get plenty of “here’s my dick at 14 different angles, please critique!” type submissions, and they’re rarely a hit with me. People who are courteous and polite in their emails have a markedly better shot of receiving a critique, and I’ve mentioned before that I will prioritize dicks of color, and any other submissions which prevent the blog from becoming an endless sea of cis Caucasian junk.

All in all, Critique My Dick Pic is proving to be an extremely positive and humbling project. It’s fun and light, but it’s also confirmed to me just how fragile men are; how crumblingly insecure and self-conscious so many of them are about their bodies. That’s very human and understandable, and it’s a terrain with which most women are familiar, but men in particular are exhorted to grin and bear their body issues rather than talk about them. Perhaps that’s why they’ve responded so openly to my project; an anonymous outlet for them to share their deepest vulnerabilities (and to swing their dicks around). It’s very humbling to be put in a trusted position like that, and even though I have a pull-no-punches approach to reviewing, I try to be careful with people’s feelings. Fundamentally, I’m doing this project to help people—senders and receivers alike. I want to rid the world of boring, artless dick pics, and I want to get everybody on board with that.


Artwork by Liza Nelson/EMOJI IRL, used with permission.

Madeleine Holden is a New Zealander with an abiding interest in criminal justice, sex, and rap music. She's on twitter @moscaddie. Visit Critique My Dick Pic here.

24 Comments / Post A Comment

Roxanne Rholes

This is seriously mind-blowing. Also, it reminds me of a dick pic a friend of mine received - the guy was holding a $20 bill next to it. NOT HOT. JUST WEIRD.


@Roxanne Rholes Maybe it was for scale?


@Roxanne Rholes "this is seriously mind-blowing."

... Phrasing!

Roxanne Rholes

@ba-na-nas yes, I'm sure it was - but a really awkward choice of object!



@ba-na-nas read this as "for sale," it was better that way.


@Roxanne Rholes bonus points to the guy if it was actually a fake $20 that was smaller than an actual bill. that's STRATEGY.


Love love love! :D@k

Rebecca V. O'Neal

Omg! I applied for THIS JOB on Craigslist I think....


I didn't realize until this posting that I have zero skills in the dick pic assessment field. I have strong and well researched opinions about sex, but I've got nothing when it comes to evaluating the cock apart from the man.

I went to your site and laughed really hard, and also giggled like a 14 year old girl. This Navy pic will have me chuckling for days.

You are doing the Lord's work, Madeleine.




oh dear lord



As an aficionado of multisyllabic elision, "indefinitely deprioritize" is a hit with me.

Slanted & Enchanted

Thank you for this article. I just spent the last twenty minutes on my new favorite tumblr. Such an amazing idea, and executed with thoughtfulness and kindness. Love!

Ken Olson@facebook

It seems you grade more on torso/legs than the actual dick pics in your website, which is kind of misleading.


@Ken Olson@facebook She grades the pics overall, not the dicks themselves.

dracula's ghost

I am now very sad that as an old married woman who never dated during the cyber age I will probably never receive a dick pic. I never thought I would be sad about such a thing. Maybe I can get my husband to send me some.




@dracula's ghost Oh my gosh, it couldn't be easier. Start a tumblr, invite your readers to share with you, and here they come! (Post some sexy stuff you like, follow other people, etc. to get some followers.)

I couldn't like this tumblr more, not least because it acknowledges women can enjoy dirty pics, too!


@dracula's ghost I'm seriously waiting for this to happen. I'm going to 'follow' you at the first opportunity.

lucy snowe

I remember after the Weiner scandal, there was so much talk about how no woman wants to receive a dick pick. I just didn't understand it. Not that I'd enjoy getting an unsolicited one from a stranger, but the happy few I've received were... well-received. Why not? It's sexy. It's nice. Why aren't women expected to have a visually stimulated sex drive? We're still people. With eyeballs and groins.

That being said, yes, backgrounds can be distracting. I think I inadvertently insulted a guy asking what the book on his coffee table was. Hey, it just means I kept looking after the first impression!


Sweet Jesus, this is the best tumblr ever. Please keep doing this indefinitely.

I had never seen a beautiful dick pic before now, and goodness me, there are some beautiful ones, and also some hilarious ones, and your review style is just perfect. Thank you so much.


Awesome side job!

Teacup Pigs


hahahha so funny :P


interesting posting... good job.. :-)
Gamis Tuneeca Diskon

Post a Comment

You must be logged-in to post a comment.

Login To Your Account