Thursday, March 17th, 2011
22

The Potato Colada

Earlier, we conquered the eating part of St. Patrick's Day, and now it's time to get down to some well-deserved drinking! I've created a signature cocktail which I call the Potato Colada.

It combines so many of the things that make Ireland great (Irish Creme, milk, tubers) into one mouth-watering beverage. Essentially, this cocktail is like alcoholic chocolate milk, which — let's face it — is the best of all possible worlds. I was originally going to serve it in a regular old glass, but then Edith suggested we drink them from potatoes, which we will obviously do because a) there is nothing more Irish than a potato, and b) how many times in your life do you have the chance to drink out of a potato?

OK, let's dive right in, because the faster we make them, the faster we can drink them!!!

Here's what you'll need:

-Irish Creme (Bailey's or any other brand is fine.)

-Milk (I used whole, but use whatever you have.)

-Chocolate syrup

-Potatoes, as large as possible (You'll need one potato for every person you plan to serve.)

-Hairpins, for garnish (Duh.)

Here's what to do:

-Combine equal parts Irish Creme and milk in a glass or pitcher. I used 1/2 cup of each, and it was more than enough to fill 2 potatoes.

-For every cup of liquid you use (just eyeball it), add one tablespoon of chocolate syrup.

-Mix it all around with a spoon until the syrup is dissolved. Taste it to make sure it's chocolate-y enough for you. If it's not, stir in more syrup. Then stick the whole thing in the fridge while you get the potatoes prepped.

-Scrub the potatoes clean, and pat them dry.

-Cut a bit off one end (maybe 1/4 of the potato), just at the point where the potato gets the widest. This creates the top of the "glass." Then you'll want to slice a tiny bit off the bottom, just enough so that there's a small flat surface for the potato to rest on so it will stay upright.

-Now you need to hollow out the potatoes. I used a teaspoon to carve out the insides — be careful not to get too close to the skin or your "glass" will spring a leak. Remove as much of the inside of the potato as possible, but be sure not to go all the way to the bottom.

-Rinse out the potatoes so no extra starch leaks into your drink. (If you do this at all ahead of time, store the potatoes in a bowl of cold water so they don't turn brown. Then dry them off thoroughly before pouring your drink in.)

Here's what you should end up with:

-Pour the drink carefully into each potato, and then garnish by stabbing one end of a hairpin into the side of the potato. And there you have it: Potato Coladas!

As you sip an endless stream of these all night, I hope you take a moment to savor both the novelty of drinking out of a potato and the novelty of drinking chocolate milk that also gets you drunk. Happy St. Patrick's Day to one and all!

22 Comments / Post A Comment

ejcsanfran (#414)

Out of hairpins. Can I use a barette instead?

Cassie Murdoch (#3,097)

Yes, especially if it has a shamrock glued to it!

Jolie Kerr (#82)

Cassie, do you think it would be okay if I hugged you?

Aah there is a Molly's Irish Creme?! Need to buy and drink immediately!

beatrixkiddo1 (#240)

Genius! I've been making whiskey milkshakes lately, (Jameson, chocolate syrup, milk, vanilla ice cream. Blend.) and this would make excellent receptacles. I think today I will add green food coloring so it looks like im drinking them because its St. Patricks Day.

Cassie Murdoch (#3,097)

Oh. My. God. I almost wish you had not said that…because whiskey milkshakes will now be the only thing I ever eat. :(

I had one of these once, it was joyous.

chicago79 (#3,793)

yes! i've made this version a couple times – vanilla ice cream, bourbon, milk, and nutella, blended. crazy good. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/08/dining/08shakerex2.html

blee (#108)

will this be the recipe that gets me to use a blender for the first time ever? maybe.

Punkie (#4,146)

Maybe some Lucky Charms as a garnish?

cherrispryte (#281)

And just like that, Cassie won my heart.

i think i would go with rum instead of whiskey here if you wanted that little bit extra kick?. also maybe over ice, with a vanilla bean as garnish?

Brunhilde (#214)

Or just add Jameson, Irish Cream + Irish Whiskey = Match made in heaven (the pub).

scully (#4,152)

This is also how the Irish make jack-o-lanterns.

punkahontas (#546)

Hm. I had some friends over this afternoon, and I just fed them apple-kale smoothies and pistachios. I am obviously not Irish.

punkahontas (#546)

(nor celebrating.)

Allison Davis (#1,263)

There's a diner up the street from me that serves a Guinness float 365 days a year. Chocolate ice cream + Guinness. (And perhaps a wee bit 'o magic, lass.) Try it at home, it is DELICIOUS. And…nutritious?

contrary (#1,958)

brb, making that.

Wow, the potato lobby must have really gotten to you! Learn more about Big Potato's attempt to win our favor here: http://blogicallyspeaking.tumblr.com/post/3944211741/big-potato-eyes-potential-new-lobbyists-parents

Post a Comment